Skip to main content

Learners Without Borders Provides Pathways For All Students

2e News

09/04/2022

Dr. Yong ZhaoHaving been inspired by Dr. Yong Zhao’s Reach for Greatness: Personalizable Education for All Children, I greatly anticipated the release of his most recent book, Learners Without Borders: New Learning Pathways for All Students, in which Dr. Zhao, a professor in the School of Education at the University of Kansas and at the Melbourne Graduate School of Education in Australia, calls for a change in education that focuses on what really matters—our students and their future. To those of us working to expand understanding and support for twice-exceptional and cognitively diverse learners, Zhao’s analysis of the challenges our education system faces today and the steps required to transform it align almost perfectly with our experiences. He calls for supporting students’ “jagged profiles;” talent development, strengths-based strategies, authentic learning, problem-based learning, enrichment, and more. He provides  practices to inspire those of us in the 2e field to effectively make change by uniting with thoughtful allies. Learners Without Borders begins with an overview of Zhao’s premise: Education reforms over the past 40 years have failed primarily because they haven’t put students at the center. Instead, education policy has tended to treat  students as just the “recipients” of intended changes. Our  current system has too many “borders” that hem in our students and educators. If we can redefine these borders (curriculum, teacher, classroom, age, graduation), then we can put students at the center. “[Students]  have their own passions and interests, strengths and weaknesses, and personal contexts,” writes Zhao. “Unless they are involved as change makers and can make schooling work for them, it is unlikely that school outcomes will change.” [perfectpullquote align=”full” bordertop=”false” cite=”” link=”” color=”” class=”” size=””]Education reforms over the past 40 years have failed primarily because they haven’t put students at the center.[/perfectpullquote]From this overview, Zhao jumps into the nitty gritty, detailing the borders that create  current school pathways and the limitations these borders impose. For instance, The Curriculum Border “applies to all teachers and students, [but] one curriculum does not work for all students… Students who are willing and able to complete the curriculum are rewarded; those who don’t are typically left behind.” The Age Border defines when a child starts kindergarten and, when combined with The Curriculum Border, what they are expected to learn and know, even though “some of them may already know the content and skills, and some others may be far behind, the assumption is that they all should know the same content and have the same skills by the end of the year, as assessed by the same tests… they have little freedom to follow their own passions and interests.” Having laid the groundwork, Zhao outlines how we can remove the borders that hold our children back. He notes that children who don’t fit the mold of the school pathway (because school doesn’t address their interests, passions, or individual differences, including neurodiversity) are more likely to drop out altogether. He calls for creating more individualized, personalized pathways that are developed through collaboration by students, teachers, and parents. He notes that “it is possible for schools to adjust curriculum and courses to provide students with a certain degree of latitude to follow their passions and develop a unique knowledge base. In other words, a school can require students to take certain courses, but the school can also allow students enough space to exercise their autonomy and self-determination.” He proposes changes in student grouping strategies, including multi-age grouping and ability-based grouping (where students have more autonomy to determine their groups), because “children reach different levels in each domain at different times for various reasons… Students of the same age do not necessarily have the same state of development and learning. Moreover, students may vary in their strength in each domain.” Zhao details how to break the curriculum and classroom borders, and the need to do so to help students become self-directed learners. Drawing on research from The New Teacher Project and the Center for Educational Policy Research, he concludes  that curriculum reforms have been largely ineffective. Zhao says that students need to become the co-owners of the curriculum in partnership with their teachers. He asks, “who has the right to create the curriculum for students to experience?… Traditionally, students are viewed as recipients of a great curriculum that is age-appropriate. So their job is to show up, work hard, and follow the teachers who follow the curriculum. When students who follow this prescription are not successful, then teachers are blamed, schools are blamed, and students are blamed… Educational reforms that are developed without involving learners can hardly succeed. This is why students can show up, work hard, and get good grades but still fail to flourish after graduation.” [perfectpullquote align=”right” bordertop=”false” cite=”” link=”” color=”” class=”” size=””]“What schools can do and should do is follow students’ human nature, treat their natural tendencies with respect, and support the cultivation of self-determination.”[/perfectpullquote] Zhao  acknowledges that all schools must provide a government-mandated “core” curriculum as well as locally-defined topics that provide the basic knowledge and skills required to thrive in a society, but that these should occupy approximately 50% of a student’s time at school, leaving an additional 50% to focus on “the abilities, knowledge, aptitudes, and other abilities that make a person unique based on his or her passions and strengths.” Breaking these borders requires large changes in the teacher’s role as well as students’, who must adapt to their part as a manager of their own learning. Drawing on “inquiry-based learning, project-based learning, problem-based learning, exploratory learning, or discovery learning,” Zhao notes “five common features” as part of breaking down classroom borders and improving the curriculum experience:
  • Students treated as active learners
  • Learning is purposeful
  • Learning is authentic
  • Learning is about uncertainty and unknowns
  • Teachers facilitate, lead, and support instead of lecture. 
Why is all of this necessary? The current borders of school systems prevent children from developing their own sense of self-efficacy. This creates problems because our ability to predict the future and know how to make our students ready for what they may face has diminished. “The future is not predetermined—rather, it is fluid. Our students participate in making that future, together with everyone else… Uncertainty is, perhaps, one of the only situations we can count on in the future… What schools can do and should do is follow students’ human nature, treat their natural tendencies with respect, and support the cultivation of self-determination.” Zhao closes Learners Without Borders by summarizing specific steps to re-make education with students at the center;
  • He  proposes that we advocate for the right educational outcomes, moving beyond short-term assessments of “learning,” because “we should not expect everyone to have the same average abilities.”
  • He encourages us to consider and aim for more “jagged profiles,” because “it is difficult to expect everyone to have the same high level of competence in all areas… It would not be possible for all students to be equally high in all these areas at the highest level, because [the qualities needed to be knowledgeable in all domains] do not necessarily support each other.”
  • He proposes that we “create alternative pathways for students,” for those who are underserved, entrepreneurial, or unique students whose passions aren’t “deeply connected to school subjects.” He encourages passion projects, genius hours, expanding elective options, inviting students to offer courses to their fellow students, allowing teachers to offer courses and learning opportunities in their areas of interest and passion, supporting student-led initiatives to change and lead their education, and exploring the school within a school model to test and try new approaches.
While Learners Without Borders is  both inspirational and practical, it is light on details in a few ways. First, it is not clear how this more progressive approach to education would address students with learning differences who might benefit from more scaffolding and direct instruction. Second, it would be useful  to go deeper in illustrating how to implement this vision across different age ranges; it might be challenging for parents and educators to help younger students develop self-determination. Lastly, Zhao may not go far enough in acknowledging that teachers, too, are often just as constrained as students by borders imposed on them by other parts of the education system. Regardless, Learners Without Borders is almost certain to motivate readers to take action. Zhao asks each person in the system to do their part to bring about change, recognizing that moving a system as large and bureaucratic as education isn’t likely to happen all at once. Instead, Zhao says, “To make the big changes will require a lot of small changes in classrooms and schools… What we need are evolutionary changes that will gradually become a revolution… There is no particular element that a school should start with, as long as the goal is to liberate students from the borders that constrain their learning.” [perfectpullquote align=”left” bordertop=”false” cite=”” link=”” color=”” class=”” size=””]Innovations in 2e can enhance our collective ability to improve the educational lives of all learners.[/perfectpullquote]Zhao’s work shows that we in the 2e world are not alone in calling for changes in our education system. We have allies pushing for changes that will support not just 2e learners, but all students. We can work together, expand our alliances and advocacy, and large-scale change in education. Experience and research has shown that what is essential for 2e students actually provides a blueprint for our entire education system. Innovations in 2e can enhance our collective ability to improve the educational lives of all learners. In addition, teachers need practical strategies that not only support 2e children, but will work for most every student. Charles Darwin said, “It is the long history of humankind (and animal kind, too) that those who learned to collaborate and improvise most effectively have prevailed.” We know that to create the changes our children need and deserve, we must expand the call to action beyond just those in the 2e and even the broader gifted education world. Leaders such as Dr. Yong Zhao espouse the value of strength-based, talent-focused educational pathways to wider audiences than we can reach on our own. There is power in working together to accelerate broader change that makes a difference for all students.  

Be Part of Something Exceptional

Be part of the growing 2e community. Subscribe for updates, attend events, or explore opportunities to visit and learn with us.

Connect With Us

We’d love to hear from you. Our team is here
to help you connect and explore.
Visit Us
Educators, researchers, and professionals are invited to visit and see how our learning environment works day to day.
Subscribe to our newsletter for free!
Stay informed with the latest news, insights, and resources for supporting twice-exceptional learners. Sign up for the 2e Center newsletter today!

Vision & Leadership in 2e Education Symposium 2027

Registration is now live

“Where research meets practice to shape the future of gifted and 2e education”

Learn More & Register